High Island, Atop a Salt Dome

High Island is an unincorporated community on the Bolivar Peninsula Northeast of Galveston Island.  It gets its name from the fact that it's located above a salt dome, causing a mound that rises about 38 feet above the rest of Bolivar Peninsula.  This makes it the highest point on the Gulf Coast, between Alabama and the Yucatán Peninsula.  The term "island" is a figure of speech used to describe this and other Gulf Coast salt domes. 

The High Island dome has been an important geological formation throughout the history of the Gulf Coast.  Artifacts found on Bolivar Peninsula indicate hunter gatherers roamed the region for thousands of years, collecting shellfish and hunting the abundant wildlife. These Native Americans may have also visited the mineral springs which used to exist on High Island.  These springs resulted from salt dome minerals mixing with groundwater.  The mineral springs were an attraction to visitors in the late 1800s.  Water from the springs was bottled and sold widely in Texas as an elixir. 

According to legend, the pirate Jean Lafitte and his crew had parties in the big grove of oak trees that covered the island when they cruised the coast in the early 1800s.  He is reputed to have buried treasure here, but so far there's no evidence to support this folklore.

Crowds of birdwatchers come to High Island during the spring migration when the beaches and woods of High Island are sometimes covered with birds migrating back to the U.S. from wintering in Central and South America. These occasions are caused by strong, turbulent headwinds and rain that usually happen when a strong, fast-moving cold front crosses the Texas coast and moves into the Gulf of Mexico. The wind and rain slows the migrating birds causing them to rapidly use up their reserves.  This means the need to land and rest at the first opportunity after the exhausting flight across the Gulf.  As a result the Audubon Society has several bird sanctuaries here.

Formation of Salt Domes

Salt deposits form when the sea rises and then recedes, trapping seawater in inland basins/bowls/lakes.  Since the water cannot flow out of these bowls (or flows out very slowly) it evaporates, leaving the salt.  Over time this happens again and again causing thick beds of salt to build up.  Then more millions of years pass and these beds of salt become covered by layers/strata of rocks and soil.   The High Island salt bed begins six miles underground, but salt is lighter that rock and soil, so it tends to rise (float up) in the layers of earth that cover it.  This pushes the strata (layers of rock and earth) up forming a bulge or dome.  As this dome pushes it way upward it bends the strata of rock it passes through and the layers above it. If the dome rises close enough to the surface it pushes the surface up causing a bump.  High Island is such a bump.

Since the maximum height of the bump at High Island is slight, it isn't a dramatic rise on the horizon.  If coming from Galveston, when you reach N 29° 32.409 W 094° 24.896, look off to your left and you will see an area that's a slightly different elevation than the surrounding area -- that's High Island. 

As the salt dome pushes up it tends to the tear different strata apart, creating voids for oil to pool.  Thus, oil wells are often drilled around the perimeter of the domes.  Oil Field Road rings High Island in a rough circle where wells have been drilled. 

Because of the nature of the area and the gentle rise of the earth it's difficult to see the mound that is High Island.  

To claim your find email me the answers to these questions (please don't put the answers in your log):

1)  The coordinates take you to a Texas Historical Marker.  With your back to the rear of the marker, looking slightly to the left and through two uprights you'll see a sign.  Tell me the words on the sign.

2)  Why do you think migrating birds come to High Island instead of other areas on the coast? 

3)  Oil Field Road makes a rough circle around the dome.  The two points where Highway 124 crosses Oil Field Road form a crude diameter of the dome.  Use your GPSr to record the coordinates of these two points.  Then use the two points to calculate the circumference of the dome (which is also the length of Oil Field Road).  Send me both coordinates you measured and the circumference of the salt dome you calculated using them.

4)  Why do you think there are trees on High Island but few to none on the surrounding areas of Bolivar Peninsula. 

5)  The salt dome has provided a form of protection for the village of people living on it.  Explain why living in High Island atop the salt dome would help protect you as opposed to living 5 miles east or west. 

Please do not post pictures that include the sign.

The exchange with the approver went like this:

It's best to start at the bottom and go up, so you read in chorological order

This log was posted on April 5th.  It was my last, the reviewer never responded.  I realize it's argumentative.  I had tried to stay away from this until it looked like all other hope was lost.  It seemed clear if this didn't work, all hope of approval was lost. 

By this time I had spent most of a day and a half constructing the cache page and replying to the approver plus half a day and $100 on a trip to High Island, so I had decided if it wasn't approved this would be my last attempt at an Earthcache, and there was nothing left to lose.  For some reason the reviewer encrypted this log, so I had to decrypt and reconstruct it.

April 5 by Thot (1307 found)

> Your second set of question is much improved over the first. #2 and #4 are good.

I've seen no requirement stated for a minimum number of questions. I think I ran across an earthcache that asked only one question, but that was a couple or three weeks ago and I wouldn't be able to find it again. If we now have two acceptable questions, aren't two enough?

> The distance [questions] can be found by using a simple mapping program.

I hate to be argumentative about this but many, if not most Earthcaches can be solved using simple Google searches. To test this I tried six local earthcaches. I solved three outright (Long Point Fault, Humble's Artesian Well, & Oil's Well That Ends Well). I could also answer the questions on [another] except for one question about what’s on a sign. In fact one of the questions suggests using the web to answer it. Another question asks for dimensions, which as you say, "could be found using a simple mapping program." I feel sure I could have done other local Earthcaches this way but, having proved the point to my satisfaction, I quit. The two I tried and couldn’t solve using the web were ones that asked for information from signs.

If it's required that some aspect of the geological formation be visible and that more than two questions are required, these constraints should be stated in the requirements.

 

 

Post Reviewer Note April 5 by geoawareUSA2

Thot,

I posted it for a few of the other Earthcache reviewers to look at. With the following notes.

The earthcache program is about teaching people about the earth. Logging requirements that are not realated do not teach the people about the location and the earth science of the area. Your writeup is one of the best that I have seen, however when the person pulls up the questions, (which is what most geocachers do first), they realize that all they need to gather is the information that is gathered for any virtual, and ignore the earth science. Though many were listed in the past, the current standard is that the questions need to relate to the science of the area.

The best kind of logging task is one that asks a visitor to go to your coordinates and make a specific observation of a specific, unique geologic feature. And then the visitor is asked to make some kind of interpretation, inference, prediction, etc., based on their own personal observations or measurements. It is best to avoid simple measurements that do not involve further thought or interpretation, such as “measure the height” or “estimate the volume” or “count the number of”. Alone, those questions do not help educate people about the earth. A better example would be something like “Describe the size and depth of these fossil dinosaur footprints. Then estimate what type of dinosaur it was and what it might have been doing when it made these footprints. Explain what observations lead you to this conclusion.” Note, this is just a general example to show how we like to get people thinking. It is not extremely important that visitors determine an exact fact. What is important is that they learn some interesting geologic concepts and think about their earth! (It is also best if the question can help show that the person really did find the correct location, without the use of photographs, which can no longer be required.).

Your second set of question is much improved over the first. #2 and #4 are good. The distance ones can be found by using a simple mapping program.

Geoawareusa2

March 30 by Thot (1307 found)

The High Island salt dome has been a prominent and important geological formation throughout the history of the Gulf coast and of Texas. This is not only because it’s the highest point on the Gulf Coast between Alabama and the Yucatán Peninsula, but because a whole town rests atop it, a town protected from hurricanes because of the salt dome. It’s also an oil field. It's also one only three salt domes in Texas that have any surface breach characteristics. It's also been useful to American Indians going back a thousand years. Due to the salt dome it was once a mineral spring resort.

To decide this is not a significant enough geological formation to qualify as an earthcache simply because questions could not be devised that complied with an arbitrary set of rules seems to be throwing out the baby because there was no bathwater. I urge you not to let the minutiae overcome the meaning.

Answer:
1) "The Great Texas Coastal Birding Trail" (I'm not asking this question about birds for birds sake. I'm asking it to demonstrate they really went THERE and are not armchair logging.)
2) The rise allows them to see the trees from out in the Gulf and when fatigued they need to stop as the first location with trees.
3) Oil Field Road Coordinates: South N 29° 33.104 W 094° 23.354 North N 29° 34.688 W 094° 23.778
Salt Dome Diameter: 1.87 miles
Salt Dome Circumference: 5.87 miles
4) The land around the salt dome is near sea level, exceptionally high tides and hurricanes cause the area to be marshy and saline, neither of which are conducive to the growth of trees.
5) The elevation caused by the salt dome helps protect against flooding from destructive tidal surges caused by hurricanes.

March 28 by geoawareUSA2

Your logging requirements have nothing to do with the geology of the area.

#1 is the text about the birding trail on the sign
#2 talks about the poles that hold the sign up
#3 can be solved by a mapping program

See the following link (visit link)

"An EarthCache must include logging tasks which relate to - and help teach - the Earth Science lesson. The logging tasks should be stringent enough that they can only be completed by cachers who have visited the EarthCache site."

"Asking cachers to complete internet research is also not a valid logging task, as it does not relate to what visitors will experience at the site."

Post Reviewer Note March 20 by Thot (1307 found)

> Please make your eartchcache logging tasks related to the geology of the area . .

Help me understand why the calculation of the circumference of the of the salt dome is not "related to the geology of the area?"


Post Reviewer Note March 19 by geoawareUSA2

Please make your eartchcache logging tasks related to the geology of the area and not just some virtual points.

I realize that this make it difficult at this location due to the fact that the geology is hidden from view.

Post Reviewer Note March 9 by Thot (1307 found)

Original Cache Location:  N 29° 34.055 W 094° 23.897

Post Reviewer Note March 9 by Thot (1307 found)

There isn't much to see here as the salt dome is below ground. The rise is only 38 feet over a 2 mile span so even the rise is difficult to see. That's why I didn't have more pertinent questions.

Answers:
1) The Great Texas Coastal Birding Trail
2) To support the roof of a shelter designed to hold/display an informational sign
3) Oil Field Road Coordinates: South N 29° 33.104 W 094° 23.354 North N 29° 34.688 W 094° 23.778
Salt Dome Diameter: 1.87 miles
Salt Dome Circumference: 5.87 miles